Curmudgeonly Movie Review: Alice in Emoland
Tuesday, March 9th, 2010So this past Friday, I was treated to a late-night showing of the new Tim Burton offering, Alice in Wonderland. I’d really been looking forward to this movie, and didn’t do any reviewing of the content beforehand, so what I got in the theatre was not at all what I walked in expecting. What did I get? Read on, my friend, read on!
I’d like to preface this with the statement that, despite how I may paint it, this is NOT a 100% bad, awful, icky film. However, I don’t think it’s worth the cost of a full-price ticket. I’ll tell you right now, wait until this flick hits the dollar theatres, or else get it off Netflix later. It’s worth seeing at least once, but you’re really not missing anything if you opt to just watch it on the small screen.
And so, let us proceed with my take on Alice in EmoWonderland.
In case you hadn’t guessed from this entry so far, the movie was awash in emo. The original books were rather dark in nature, but I don’t recall them being a wannabe-goth teen’s “moist sleep-vision.” What you get from this movie is the Mad Hatter and his tea party guests mourning the loss of the old days before the Red Queen took over their fair land and turned it into a grey, foggy, overcast, post-apocalyptic wasteland. Very little action to be had. A lot of depressed people shuffling around acting depressed because their lives are depressing, and it depresses them.
The happily-absurd dialogue that made the books so endearing was almost entirely stricken from the film, leaving the audience with nothing but the ever-present emo to cling onto. An attempt at the entertaining insanity of the original stories was made with the Mad Hatter, but it seems the film’s writers confused “constantly-changing accent” with “mental instability.” One second Johnny Depp wath thlurring hith wordth juth like thith; the next, he was breaking into a brogue that lay somewhere between Ireland and Scotland; the next-next, he was attempting to sound like a classic English gentleman. And his behaviour, ranging from childlike whimsy to nearly homicidal, combined with his creepy fixation on Alice that apparently began when he met her as a six-year-old girl, just made many of us in my group uncomfortable. The only character that really captured the story’s original spirit was the happily-macabre, cheeky Cheshire Cat, voiced by Stephen Fry, who had a chuckle-inducing obsession with the Mad Hatter’s hat, to the point of repeatedly asking to inherit it on the eve of the Hatter’s intended–and of course failed–execution. But the Cat had hardly any face time in the movie at all (and I don’t mean that his face was just invisible, either).
The scenery was, as I just mentioned, pretty much all drab, done in greys and browns, with the exception of a few garden scenes. The Red Queen’s palace was cast in deep reds and browns that still somehow managed to look muted. The only colour that wasn’t washed out was in the White Queen’s domain, where bright pink cherry blossom trees and white castle walls offered a little bit o’ fresh air, a nice break from the greyness of the rest of the environment. And with the exception of the White Queen’s realm, most of the buildings in the movie were decayed and crumbling, another nod to the whole “post-apocalyptic wasteland” theme that is so overdone in modern popular media. The Red Queen is BAD for the realm. We GET it, okay? We got it within the first five minutes of Alice’s trip down the rabbit-hole!
This is pretty much the most colour you’ll see in the setting for about 90% of the movie.

And as if to drive in the depressing point that this ain’t your grandmother’s Wonderland even further, the movie informs us that the name of the realm is actually UNDERland, and Alice just misheard it. (Being a Venture Bros. fan, I was VERY disappointed that Baron Ünderbheit didn’t show up at this point, hehe. At least he would’ve introduced some ACTION into Underland.)
The story is almost nonexistent. I’d include a spoiler warning, but there’s not enough substance to this movie’s story for it to HAVE spoilers. The adult Alice runs away from an undesirable suitor who’s just proposed and falls down the rabbit hole to the fantasy land she visited as a child. Everyone tells her she’s going to kill the Jabberwocky, she insists she’s not going to kill the Jabberwocky, but then she decides she IS going to kill the Jabberwocky after all. Then she kills the Jabberwocky and immediately goes home. The end. There are no surprises, no plot twists. Pretty much every plot point can be seen coming from the moment the relevant character is introduced. The main aim of the movie is supposed to be how Alice stops doing what others want her to do and learns to make her own choices…by doing exactly what everyone wants her to do in fighting the Jabberwocky. Yeah, I didn’t really get it either.
Also, Burton claims this film is his take on the books, not a sequel. But it’s made clear in the movie that it takes place after the books because Alice has already BEEN to W/Underland and had the adventures we know and love from the stories and various film adaptations. So, um. Dude, it’s a sequel. And giving a sequel the same name as the original usually has (the full title of the first book being Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland) rather confused me at first since I went into the film content-blind.
Now, maybe this bit is coming too little too late, but I wanted to end on a high–well, highER–note, and re-state that I didn’t flat-out hate the movie. Drabness aside, the visuals are otherwise appealing, with that twisted quality in both characters and environment that is immediately identifiable as Tim Burton’s touch. Some of the CG stands out as CG, such as horses that don’t move quite like real horses, but most of it is so well-done that the little kinks don’t matter. I may not be a huge fan of most of the guy’s movies, but I do love the special effects that get stuck into his films.
Stephen Fry makes a brilliant Cheshire Cat. Alan Rickman as the Caterpillar is just perfect, and I really wish we’d gotten to see more of him. And Christopher Lee as the voice of the Jabberwocky? Lee excels in everything he does, so I’ve no complaints here! Anne Hathaway, the White Queen, was JUST the right amount of sugary-sweet and twisted, making her one of the more interesting protagonists.
Look, I know the good points about this movie are mostly superficial, but sometimes that’s all you need. I think it’s worth seeing at least once–just not at full ticket price, a sentiment that was shared by the other ten people in my group. What story there IS is too depressing to appeal to children, but too nonexistent to appeal to adults. I think the flick was best summed up by something that happened when the eleven of us were standing outside the theatre afterwards. One of my friends remarked, “Y’know, if I was an emo wannabe-goth teenager, I’d probably think that movie was the bomb diggity or whatever.” At that moment, a group of teenagers came out of the theatre, decked out in black fishnet stockings far too tight for their chunky legs and wearing the Hot Topic version of black goth-gear (which is to say, not goth AT ALL). One was wearing a red velvet crown; another wearing a solid black miniature top hat to mimic the Mad Hatter’s, trimmed with black lace and black fake raven feathers. The group was talking rather enthusiastically about the film…well, mainly about how hot Johnny Depp was. Folks, I do believe we’ve identified the movie’s target audience.
Watch this movie as a way to kill some time and ogle some interesting graphics. And the movie did have its funny moments when it wasn’t on the verge of slitting its own wrists. I’d say, watch this one at home with a group of friends and some good food, and don’t hold back on the MST3K commentary. You’ll likely get much more out of it than you would in the theatre.
Tune in next time, when I’ll probably ruin someone else’s childhood!
P.S. Spwug’s own Donnie Sturges recommended this hi-larious link to me, and I think it’s a fine way to end this post. From College Humor: Tim Burton’s Secret Formula.














